'Show Some Respect to Books': Supreme Court Halts Ad-Hoc Shifting of 135-Year-Old Central Secretariat Library Collection
Court category: Supreme Court
Court / details: Supreme Court of India
Location: New Delhi, India
Pulling up the Union Government for an 'ad-hoc approach' to relocating 8.5 lakh books—including rare volumes from 1702—from the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library under the Central Vista plan, the Supreme Court halted all shifting until 20 November 2026 and demanded concrete preservation safeguards.
CASE DETAILS AT A GLANCE
- Case Title: Suo Motu Writ / Heritage Relocation Proceeding Concerning Central Secretariat Library (CSL)
- Court: Supreme Court of India
- Bench: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva
- Order Date: 16 November 2026 (Next Hearing: 20 November 2026)
- Constitutional & Legal Principles Involved: Article 21 and Article 49 of the Constitution of India (Protection of Heritage and Cultural Institutions); Judicial Review of Administrative Action
- Core Holding: Criticising the Central Government's 'ad-hoc approach' to relocating the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library housing over 8.5 lakh books (including rare works dating back to 1702) from Shastri Bhawan, the Supreme Court prohibited any shifting of books until 20 November 2026 and demanded verified assurance of proper storage and preservation infrastructure.
1. Executive Overview and Public Heritage Significance
Established in 1891 in Calcutta as the Imperial Secretariat Library, shifted to Delhi in 1911, and housed across four floors (nearly 5,500 sq. m.) of Shastri Bhawan since 1969, the Central Secretariat Library (CSL) is one of India's most treasured intellectual and administrative archives. Its collection exceeds 8.5 lakh books, official gazetteers, and rare manuscripts—including a 1702 compilation of French travel writings—and serves researchers, civil servants, and thousands of competitive-examination students.
When the Central Public Works Department (CPWD) issued a notice in September 2026 to vacate Shastri Bhawan for Central Vista redevelopment (proposed Kartavya Bhawan-4, scheduled for completion in December 2028), reports surfaced that inadequate temporary rooms had been earmarked for the library and that two lakh books previously shifted to R.K. Puram had languished in poor conditions for 15 years. On 16 November 2026, Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva intervened decisively to protect this national heritage.
2. The 16 November 2026 Hearing and Judicial Rebuke
During the hearing, Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati informed the Bench via affidavit that approximately 5,583 sq. m. had been earmarked for the Central Secretariat Library and Tulsi Sadan Library in Kartavya Bhawan-4, and that until its completion in December 2028, books would be temporarily moved to 3,890.45 sq. m. at the General Pool Office Accommodation (GPOA), Block-2, Netaji Nagar (with capacity for about 6.25 lakh books).
However, aided by Senior Advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan as amicus curiae, the Bench spotted glaring gaps: the 8.5 lakh-book collection exceeded the temporary 6.25 lakh-book capacity, the affidavit was not even properly on the court record during the hearing, and books stored earlier in R.K. Puram were reportedly in 'atrocious condition'. Rebuking the Centre's ad-hoc planning, the Bench remarked pointedly: 'Show these books some respect… this is some heritage. Basically, a heritage for us dating back to 1702. If you don't want them, give them to some other country that will value them.'
3. Interim Restraint and Accountability Roadmap
Recording the Centre's assurance and imposing a binding judicial freeze, the Supreme Court ordered that no books from the Central Secretariat Library shall be shifted until the next hearing on 20 November 2026, compelling the Union Government to demonstrate tangible infrastructure readiness, climate-controlled storage for rare 1702 volumes, and uninterrupted public access before touching a single shelf.
4. Practical Implications for Public Institutions and Heritage Litigation
- Infrastructure Readiness Before Demolition: Urban redevelopment projects cannot treat libraries, archives, and cultural institutions as expendable office furniture; equivalent, verified accommodation must be ready before vacating heritage premises.
- Power of Amicus & Suo Motu Oversight: Constitutional courts will actively halt administrative relocation orders under Articles 21 and 49 when priceless public knowledge repositories face irreversible damage.
Stay updated on Supreme Court public-law and heritage rulings at https://sklawhouse.com/posts.
5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Why did the Supreme Court stop the shifting of Central Secretariat Library books on 16 November 2026?
Because the Centre proposed relocating 8.5 lakh books (including rare 1702 volumes) into temporary accommodation with lower capacity (6.25 lakh books) without demonstrating proper preservation readiness.
Until when is the shifting of the Central Secretariat Library halted?
The Supreme Court barred any relocation of the books until the next hearing on 20 November 2026.
