G.O. Ms. No. 94 (16.03.2024) Operates Retrospectively — DTCP Must Allow 10% Guideline Value Payment Instead of OSR Land for Unsold Plots Up to 5,000 Sq.M.: Madras HC in K. Velusamy (2026)
Court category: High Court
Court / details: Madras High Court (Madurai Bench)
Location: Dindigul / Madurai / Chennai / Vandavasi, Tamil Nadu
Madras High Court (Madurai Bench) in K. Velusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu (W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025, 04 Mar 2026) quashes DTCP Dindigul's refusal dated 19.03.2025, holding that G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 amending Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Regularisation Rules operates retrospectively by substitution, allowing layouts with unsold plots up to 5,000 sq.m. to pay 10% guideline value in lieu of 10% OSR land.
CASE DETAILS AT A GLANCE
- Case Title: K. Velusamy v. The State of Tamil Nadu (Rep. by Secretary, Housing & Urban Development Department), The Commissioner of Town and Country Planning (Chennai), and The Joint Director, District Town and Country Planning (Dindigul)
- Case Number: W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025 & W.M.P.(MD) No. 8218 of 2025
- Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras (Madurai Bench)
- Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Hemant Chandangoudar
- Date of Judgment: 04 March 2026
- Counsel Appearing: Mr. S. Sades Kumar for Petitioner; Mr. P. Subbaraj, Special Government Pleader for Respondents
- Impugned Proceedings Quashed: Na.Ka.No.3973/2024 Thi.Maa.3 dated 19.03.2025 issued by the Joint Director, District Town and Country Planning (DTCP), Dindigul
- Statutes, Rules & G.O.s Involved: Section 113 and Section 122 of the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act, 1971; Rule 7(g)(ii) of the Tamil Nadu Regularisation of Unapproved Layouts and Plots Rules, 2017 (originally notified under G.O. Ms. No. 78 dated 04.05.2017 and G.O. Ms. No. 172 dated 13.10.2017); G.O. Ms. No. 94, Housing and Urban Development Department, dated 16.03.2024; Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act, 1908; Article 226 of the Constitution of India
- Core Holding: An amendment made by way of 'substitution' of an existing statutory rule—such as G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 substituting Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Regularisation Rules—relates back to the date of the original rule unless the rule-making authority expressly indicates prospective operation. Consequently, even layouts regularised prior to 16.03.2024 having unsold plot areas up to 5,000 sq.m. are legally entitled to pay 10% of the prevailing guideline value in lieu of reserving 10% physical Open Space Reservation (OSR) land and convert the reserved land into regular housing plots.
1. INTRODUCTION & PLANNING SIGNIFICANCE ACROSS TAMIL NADU
Across Tamil Nadu—from fast-expanding urban corridors in Chennai, Coimbatore, Madurai, and Dindigul to mofussil taluk headquarters like Vandavasi, Cheyyar, Arani, and Tiruvannamalai—thousands of layout promoters and landowners who regularised unapproved layouts under the Tamil Nadu Regularisation of Unapproved Layouts and Plots Rules, 2017 faced an acute practical and financial deadlock. Under the unamended Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Rules, promoters seeking regularisation of unsold plots were compelled to physically reserve 10% of the total unsold plot area as Open Space Reservation (OSR) by amalgamating or altering unsold plots, even when the layout had been partially sold out years earlier and the remaining unsold plots were scattered in small, non-contiguous pockets completely unsuitable for a functional public park or playground.
In countless cases across Tamil Nadu, this rigid requirement froze valuable residential land in limbo. Promoters could not sell the plots earmarked for fragmented OSR, local bodies (Town Panchayats, Village Panchayats, and Municipalities) showed little interest in taking over tiny, disconnected 1,000 to 3,000 sq.ft. strips as parks, and the land simply deteriorated into overgrown vacant lots. Recognizing this widespread urban-planning failure and the genuine hardship faced by small and medium layout owners, the Government of Tamil Nadu issued G.O. Ms. No. 94, Housing and Urban Development Department, dated 16.03.2024.
By G.O. Ms. No. 94, the State Government substituted Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Rules to introduce a pragmatic alternative for layouts having an unsold plot area up to 5,000 square metres: the applicant may either provide 10% of the unsold plot area as physical Open Space Reservation or pay an amount equivalent to 10% of the prevailing guideline value of the unsold plot area. Despite this clear policy shift, District Town and Country Planning (DTCP) offices across Tamil Nadu began rejecting applications from promoters whose layouts had already been regularised prior to 16.03.2024, taking a rigid administrative stance that G.O. Ms. No. 94 operated only prospectively for future regularisation orders.
In K. Velusamy v. The State of Tamil Nadu (W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025, decided on 04 March 2026), Justice Hemant Chandangoudar of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court struck down this hyper-technical refusal. Applying settled principles of statutory interpretation on 'amendment by substitution' and beneficial subordinate legislation, the High Court held that G.O. Ms. No. 94 relates back to the inception of the 2017 Rules and applies to pre-2024 regularised layouts as well. This judgment is a major landmark for DTCP compliance, layout conversion, and Sub-Registrar registration across Tamil Nadu.
2. COMPLETE FACTUAL & PROCEDURAL CHRONOLOGY
The litigation in K. Velusamy arose from a regularised residential layout in Dindigul District and followed a clean, undisputed chronological sequence:
- Formation of 'CM Golden Nagar' Residential Layout: The petitioner, K. Velusamy, owned patta agricultural/convertible lands comprised in Survey Nos. 88/6 and 89/6, measuring a total extent of 1.83 acres, in Dindigul District. He developed the land into a residential layout under the name and style of 'CM Golden Nagar'.
- Carving of 32 Plots & Pre-Regularisation Sale of 16 Plots: Within 'CM Golden Nagar', a total of 32 residential plots were laid out. Prior to the cut-off and regularisation proceedings, 16 plots were already sold to individual buyers through registered sale deeds, leaving 16 unsold plots in the ownership of the petitioner.
- Regularisation Under the 2017 Rules & Earmarking of 3,224.64 Sq.M. as OSR: Following the introduction of the Tamil Nadu Regularisation of Unapproved Layouts and Plots Rules, 2017 (read with the registration ban under Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act, 1908), the petitioner applied for regularisation of the remaining 16 unsold plots. Under the unamended Rule 7(g)(ii) then in force, an extent of 3,224.64 square metres was reserved as Open Space Reservation (OSR) at the time DTCP granted regularisation.
- Issuance of G.O. Ms. No. 94 Dated 16.03.2024: Subsequent to the regularisation of the petitioner's layout, the Housing and Urban Development Department promulgated G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024, substituting Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Rules to permit layouts with unsold plot areas up to 5,000 sq.m. to pay 10% of the prevailing guideline value in lieu of physical OSR land.
- Petitioner's Application to Avail the Monetary OSR Option: Because the reserved extent / unsold plot area (3,224.64 sq.m.) fell comfortably below the 5,000 sq.m. statutory ceiling, K. Velusamy submitted a formal application to the 3rd respondent (Joint Director, DTCP, Dindigul) requesting permission to remit 10% of the prevailing guideline value in lieu of reserving physical OSR land, so that he could retain and convert the 3,224.64 sq.m. into saleable housing plots.
- Impugned Rejection Dated 19.03.2025: By proceedings in Na.Ka.No.3973/2024 Thi.Maa.3 dated 19.03.2025, the Joint Director, DTCP, Dindigul rejected the petitioner's request on the sole ground that G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 came into force subsequent to the regularisation of the petitioner's layout and therefore its benefit could not be extended to previously regularised layouts.
- Institution of Writ Petition W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025: Aggrieved by the refusal dated 19.03.2025, K. Velusamy invoked Article 226 of the Constitution before the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court seeking a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to quash the DTCP communication and direct calculation of 10% guideline value under G.O. Ms. No. 94.
3. STATUTORY & LEGISLATIVE EVOLUTION: RULE 7(g)(ii) FROM 2017 TO 2024
Understanding why the Madras High Court rejected DTCP's prospective-only interpretation requires tracing the legislative arc of layout regularisation in Tamil Nadu under the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act, 1971.
3.1 Section 22-A(2) & The 2017 Regularisation Framework
Following the Madras High Court's public interest litigation orders curbing unplanned real estate plotting in 2016 and the operationalization of Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act, 1908 (effective 20.10.2016), Sub-Registrars were prohibited from registering any sale deed of an unapproved house site unless it was approved by the planning authority or regularised. To provide a structured exit for existing unapproved layouts formed on or before 20.10.2016, the State framed the Tamil Nadu Regularisation of Unapproved Layouts and Plots Rules, 2017 (originally G.O. Ms. No. 78 dated 04.05.2017, modified by G.O. Ms. No. 172 dated 13.10.2017) in exercise of powers under Section 122 read with Section 113 of the Town and Country Planning Act, 1971.
3.2 The Original Text of Rule 7(g)(ii) (Unamended)
As originally framed, Rule 7(g)(ii) mandated physical reservation of OSR from unsold plots without any monetary-payment alternative: 'The reservation of land for Open Space Reservation shall be provided by amalgamating or altering the unsold plots to an extent not less than 10% of the total area of unsold plots. However, it would not be essential to provide 10% of the unsold plot area in a layout in one contiguous stretch or in definite dimension.'
In practice, allowing non-contiguous, irregular 10% fragments across partially sold layouts defeated the very purpose of OSR (which is to provide usable parks and recreational lungs for residents) while simultaneously locking up promoters' unsold inventory.
3.3 The 2024 Substitution via G.O. Ms. No. 94 Dated 16.03.2024
To cure this anomaly, the Housing and Urban Development Department issued G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024, which amended Rule 7(g)(ii) through an express substitution clause:
'In the said Rules, in rule 7, in clause (g), in sub-clause (II), for the expression 'The reservation of land for Open Space Reservation shall be provided by amalgamating or altering the unsold plots to an extent not less than 10% of the total area of unsold plots. However, it would not be essential to provide 10% of the unsold plot area in a layout in one contiguous stretch or in definite dimension', the expression '10 % of the unsold plot area shall be provided as Open Space Reservation. However, in respect of the layouts having unsold plot area upto 5000 Sq.m., the applicant shall either provide 10% of unsold plot area as Open Space Reservation or pay the amount equivalent to 10% of the prevailing guideline value of the unsold plot area' shall be substituted.'
3.4 Controlling Principle: Substitution vs. Prospective Insertion
In statutory interpretation—consistently settled by the Supreme Court of India and Madras High Court—an amendment by substitution completely effaces the old text from the statute book and puts the new text in its place from the date of the original enactment, unless the amending notification contains an express saving or prospective-commencement clause. Conversely, where the legislature intends an amendment to operate only for future transactions, it uses phrases like 'with effect from the date of publication of this notification' or 'shall apply to applications filed on or after...'. G.O. Ms. No. 94 contained zero prospective limitation. Therefore, by operation of law, Rule 7(g)(ii) as substituted by G.O. Ms. No. 94 relates back to 2017.
4. COMPETING SUBMISSIONS OF COUNSEL
4.1 Submissions for the Petitioner (Mr. S. Sades Kumar)
- Retrospective Effect of Substitution: Learned counsel submitted that G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 expressly amended Rule 7(g)(ii) by way of 'substitution' without restricting its application prospectively. Consequently, the substituted rule relates back to the original 2017 Rules and governs the petitioner's layout as well.
- Eligibility Within 5,000 Sq.M. Threshold: The extent reserved in 'CM Golden Nagar' (3,224.64 sq.m.) is well below the 5,000 sq.m. ceiling prescribed by G.O. Ms. No. 94, making the petitioner squarely eligible to pay 10% of the prevailing guideline value.
- No Prejudice to Revenue or Planning Discipline: The petitioner is offering to pay 10% of the prevailing (current) guideline value—not the lower 2017 value—ensuring full revenue protection to the State while converting an unusable fragmented OSR pocket into lawful, regularised housing plots.
- Arbitrariness of Impugned Communication: Rejecting the request merely on the ground that regularisation occurred prior to 16.03.2024 is arbitrary, discriminatory against earlier compliant applicants, and contrary to the beneficial object of G.O. Ms. No. 94.
4.2 Submissions for the State & DTCP (Mr. P. Subbaraj, Special Government Pleader)
- Finality of Earlier Regularisation: Appearing for the Housing and Urban Development Department, the Commissioner of Town and Country Planning, and the Joint Director (DTCP, Dindigul), the Special Government Pleader contended that the petitioner's layout had already been regularised under the unamended 2017 Rules prior to 16.03.2024, with 3,224.64 sq.m. earmarked as OSR.
- Prospective Application of Executive G.O.s: It was argued that G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 came into force subsequent to the regularisation of the petitioner's layout, and executive/subordinate amendments ordinarily apply prospectively to pending or new regularisation applications, not concluded files.
5. COURT'S POINT-BY-POINT ANALYSIS & PRECEDENT SYNTHESIS
After examining the pleadings, the text of G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024, and the impugned order dated 19.03.2025, Justice Hemant Chandangoudar rejected the State's contentions through four clear legal holdings:
5.1 Amendment by Substitution Relates Back to Original Rule Date (Paragraph 7)
The Court anchored its decision in the foundational canon of statutory construction: 'In statutory interpretation, the substitution of a rule generally relates back to the date of the original rule, unless the amending authority expressly indicates that it is to operate prospectively. In the present case, G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 does not specify prospective operation; therefore, the amendment to Rule 7 is to be construed as operating retrospectively.' Because the Government chose the word 'substituted' without any prospective-only rider, DTCP officers could not invent a cut-off date that the Government itself omitted.
5.2 Beneficial & Enabling Provisions Demand Purposive Construction (Paragraphs 8 & 10)
Evaluating the nature of G.O. Ms. No. 94, the Court emphasized that the amendment is manifestly beneficial and enabling—designed to resolve the practical gridlock of tiny OSR reservations by giving small-layout applicants an alternative compliance pathway. In paragraph 10, the Court stated: 'It is a well-settled principle that beneficial and enabling provisions introduced by way of statutory amendments or executive orders should be interpreted in a manner that advances the object of the legislation and not in a manner that defeats the purpose of such amendment.'
5.3 Availing an Alternative Mode Does Not Reopen Regularisation (Paragraph 9)
Addressing the department's concern about reopening concluded regularisation orders, the Court clarified that the petitioner was not seeking to cancel, unsettle, or reopen the validity of his earlier layout regularisation. On the contrary, the layout's regularised status remained intact; the petitioner merely sought to avail the newly introduced monetary-payment option for dealing with the unsold plot / OSR obligation.
5.4 Mandatory Duty of DTCP to Calculate & Accept 10% Guideline Value (Paragraphs 11–12)
Once the Government created a statutory choice between reserving 10% land or paying 10% of the prevailing guideline value for unsold plot areas up to 5,000 sq.m., DTCP authorities are legally bound to process such requests in accordance with the amended rule. Denying the option solely due to the date of the earlier regularisation order was arbitrary and illegal.
5.5 Crucial Distinction: Earmarked Unsold OSR vs. Already Gifted & Vested Public Parks
Practitioners must carefully distinguish K. Velusamy (04 Mar 2026) from cases where OSR park land has already been gifted free of cost via a registered Gift Deed to a Municipality, Corporation, or Panchayat and developed as a public park. Under settled Supreme Court precedent in Association of Vasanth Apartment Owners v. V. Gopinath (2023 INSC 123) and the Madras High Court Division Bench ruling in Tax Payers Welfare Association v. Principal Secretary (10 Aug 2026 — covered in Post 7 of this batch), once OSR land is gifted and vested in the local body as a public park, it becomes public trust property and cannot be reconverted into residential plots. By contrast, K. Velusamy governs regularisation of unapproved layouts under Rule 7(g)(ii) of the 2017 Rules where the unsold plot area is up to 5,000 sq.m. and the promoter seeks to substitute 10% guideline value payment for the Rule 7(g)(ii) OSR requirement.
6. OPERATIVE DIRECTIONS & PRACTICAL DTCP / SRO PROTOCOL
Allowing W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025, Justice Hemant Chandangoudar issued the following operative order:
- Impugned Order Quashed: The Joint Director's communication dated 19.03.2025 (Na.Ka.No.3973/2024 Thi.Maa.3) is quashed in full.
- Mandatory Calculation of 10% Prevailing Guideline Value: The 3rd respondent (Joint Director, DTCP, Dindigul) is directed to calculate 10% of the prevailing guideline value for the extent of 3,224.64 sq.m. in Survey Nos. 88/6 and 89/6.
- Liberty to Convert Into Housing Plots: Upon payment of the calculated amount by the petitioner, the petitioner shall be at liberty to convert the said land into housing plots in accordance with law.
6.1 Step-by-Step Practical Protocol for Promoters & Advocates Across Tamil Nadu
- Audit Existing Regularisation Orders (2017–2024): If you or your client hold a DTCP regularisation order issued under the 2017 Rules where 10% unsold plot area (up to 5,000 sq.m.) was earmarked as OSR (and not yet irreversibly gifted and developed as a municipal park), verify the exact square-metre extent.
- Pull Current TNREGINET Guideline Value Extract: Download the current prevailing Guideline Value for the exact Survey/Sub-Division number from TNREGINET to estimate the 10% OSR fee liability before applying.
- Submit Formal Application Under Substituted Rule 7(g)(ii): File a written representation before the jurisdictional Assistant/Deputy/Joint Director of DTCP enclosing: (a) copy of the original regularisation proceedings and approved layout sketch; (b) statement of sold vs. unsold plots proving total unsold area is within 5,000 sq.m.; (c) current Encumbrance Certificate; (d) current TNREGINET Guideline Value sheet; and (e) copy of the Madras High Court judgment in K. Velusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu (W.P.(MD) No. 11011 of 2025, 04.03.2026).
- Request Revised Plot-Conversion / Regularisation Proceeding: Upon DTCP issuing the demand challan for 10% of the prevailing guideline value, remit the amount promptly and obtain the revised DTCP proceeding approving the converted housing plots.
- Present Plot Deeds at SRO Without Section 22-A(2) Obstruction: Once DTCP issues the revised approval/regularisation order for the converted plots, furnish it to the Sub-Registrar under the 2017 Rules so individual plot sale deeds are registered smoothly without Section 22-A(2) refusal.
- Invoke Writ Jurisdiction If DTCP Still Cites 'Prospective Only': If any DTCP office rejects a post-2024 request on the ground that the layout was regularised prior to 16.03.2024, file a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus citing K. Velusamy (04.03.2026) for swift quashing.
6.2 Worked Guideline Value Calculation & Practical Financial Illustration Under G.O. Ms. No. 94
To understand the real-world financial and planning impact of K. Velusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu (04.03.2026) for layout promoters across Tamil Nadu, consider a practical illustration matching the exact parameters of the judgment. Suppose a promoter in Tiruvannamalai, Dindigul, or Villupuram District regularised an unapproved layout of 1.80 acres under the 2017 Rules, leaving 3,224.64 square metres (approximately 34,710 square feet) of unsold plot area / reserved OSR pocket. Under the unamended Rule 7(g)(ii), that entire 3,224.64 sq.m. (or 10% of the unsold area) remained frozen and unsaleable. Now assume the prevailing TNREGINET Guideline Value for that street or survey number is Rs. 300 per square foot (or Rs. 3,229 per square metre).
- Step 1 — Compute Total Market/Guideline Value of the Unsold Extent: 34,710 sq.ft. multiplied by Rs. 300 per sq.ft. equals Rs. 1,04,13,000.
- Step 2 — Compute 10% Guideline Value Equivalent Under Substituted Rule 7(g)(ii): 10% of Rs. 1,04,13,000 equals Rs. 10,41,300 (payable to DTCP / designated head of account as demanded by the Joint Director or Deputy Director of DTCP).
- Step 3 — Net Unlocking of Saleable Residential Plots: Upon remitting Rs. 10,41,300 and obtaining the revised DTCP conversion/regularisation order, the promoter lawfully unlocks the entire 34,710 sq.ft. for individual housing-plot sale deeds, fully compliant with Section 22-A(2) of the Registration Act, 1908.
Advocates should always cross-check the exact wording of the DTCP demand notice to ensure that the 10% calculation is applied strictly to the prevailing guideline value of the qualifying unsold plot area (up to 5,000 sq.m.) and does not duplicate regularisation charges already paid during the original 2017–2023 regularisation proceedings.
7. RELATED UPDATES ON SK LAW HOUSE
Explore all 10 articles in our 2026 Tamil Nadu DTCP, Layout Approval, G.O. Ms. No. 70 Regularisation, OSR Protection, and Section 38 Deemed Release series at https://sklawhouse.com/posts.
8. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)
Does G.O. Ms. No. 94 dated 16.03.2024 apply to layouts regularised before March 2024?
Yes. In K. Velusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu (04 March 2026), the Madras High Court held that G.O. Ms. No. 94 amended Rule 7(g)(ii) by substitution without specifying prospective operation, and therefore operates retrospectively from the date of the 2017 Regularisation Rules.
What is the maximum unsold plot area eligible for the 10% guideline value option instead of physical OSR land?
Under the substituted Rule 7(g)(ii), layouts having an unsold plot area up to 5,000 square metres (approx. 53,819 sq.ft.) can opt to pay 10% of the prevailing guideline value instead of reserving 10% physical OSR land.
Which guideline value rate applies when calculating the 10% OSR payment—2017 or current?
The rule expressly specifies 10% of the prevailing guideline value—meaning the guideline value in force at the time of calculation and payment, as directed by the High Court in K. Velusamy.
Can a promoter convert already-gifted public park OSR land into residential plots using G.O. Ms. No. 94?
No. Once OSR park land has been gifted free of cost to a local body via a registered Gift Deed and dedicated for public park use, it cannot be diverted into residential plots (see Tax Payers Welfare Association, 10 Aug 2026). G.O. Ms. No. 94 applies to the Rule 7(g)(ii) unsold-plot OSR obligation in 2017-Rules regularised layouts up to 5,000 sq.m.
Will the Sub-Registrar register the newly converted housing plots after payment of 10% guideline value?
Yes, once DTCP accepts the 10% guideline value payment and issues the revised regularisation/plot-conversion approval, the plots stand lawfully regularised and can be registered at the Sub-Registrar Office without Section 22-A(2) objection.
Location-wise Internal Links
- Advocate Office Services in Vandavasi (Vandavasi)
- Delhi Advocate Office Services at Vandavasi (Vandavasi)
- Document Writer Services in Vandavasi (Vandavasi)
- Lawyer Office Services in Vandavasi (Vandavasi)
Related City Articles
- Lock & Seal Without Prior Notice Costs CMDA Rs. 75,000 + Immediate De-Sealing, While Lawful Section 57 Seals Require Section 80-A Revision — Madras HC (2026)
- Section 38 Deemed Release of Reserved Road/DDP Land After 3 Years Without Acquisition — Madras HC in Janab S. Moosa Kamal & D. Kamalam (2026)
- TNCDBR 2019 Prevails Over Non-Statutory Layout Conditions — Multi-Storey Apartments, Section 49 & Rule 6(8) Form-B: Madras HC in Choodamani Narayanan (2026)
- OSR Parks Cannot Be Converted, But Unutilized 'Reading Room / Community Hall' Facility Plots Can Be Converted After 5 Years — Madras HC Division Bench in Tax Payers Welfare Assn (Aug 2026)
