Skip to main content

SK Law House Legal Articles

Law updates, legal guidance, and practical articles for clients and readers of `sklawhouse.com`.

2026-11-18 21:54:12

Serving Soldiers Eligible Under Ex-Servicemen Quota Within One Year of Discharge, But Post-Notification Equivalence Certificate Bars TNPSC Selection: Madras High Court

Court category: High Court

Court / details: Madras High Court (Principal Seat)

Location: Ranipet / Chennai, Tamil Nadu

In Eswaran v. The Secretary, TNPSC (2026:MHC:4518), the Madras High Court clarified that while serving soldiers due for discharge within one year qualify as Ex-Servicemen under Section 63(2) of the 2016 Act, an Equivalence Certificate obtained after the TNPSC notification date cannot confer eligibility.

City relevance: Chennai

CASE DETAILS AT A GLANCE

  • Case Title: Eswaran v. The Secretary, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC) & 4 Others
  • Case Number: W.P. No. 7752 of 2023 (with W.M.P. Nos. 7950 & 7953 of 2023)
  • Neutral Citation: 2026:MHC:4518
  • Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras (Principal Seat, Chennai)
  • Bench: The Hon'ble Mr. Justice C. Kumarappan
  • Date of Decision: 2 November 2026
  • Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. A. Gokulakrishnan for Mr. K. Sasidran
  • Counsel for TNPSC (R1 & R2): Mr. B. Vijay, Standing Counsel
  • Counsel for Defence Authorities (R3 & R4): Ms. Sunitha Kumari, Senior Panel Counsel
  • Counsel for Higher Education Dept. (R5): Mr. P.K. Shivakumar, Government Advocate
  • Key Provisions & Precedents: Section 63(2) & Schedule-XII, Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016; G.O.(Ms).No.91 (13.09.2021); G.O.(Ms).No.130, Higher Education (K1) Department (24.07.2024); Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman A. v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2014 (3) CTC 433 (FB); State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalatha, (2020) 19 SCC 430; Sudhir Singh v. State of U.P., [2023] 14 SCR 135; Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan, (2011) 12 SCC 85

1. EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW & LEGAL SIGNIFICANCE

Public recruitment notifications issued by the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC) routinely raise intricate eligibility questions for Armed Forces personnel transitioning to civilian Government service. Two recurring issues dominate such litigation: first, whether a soldier who is still in active military service on the date of the recruitment notification—but scheduled to be discharged within twelve months—qualifies for age relaxation and reservation under the Ex-Servicemen (ESM) quota; and second, whether a technical Trade Proficiency Certificate obtained in the Army can be validated retrospectively through a Government Equivalence Order issued after the recruitment notification date.

In Eswaran v. The Secretary, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (2026:MHC:4518), decided on 2 November 2026, Justice C. Kumarappan of the Madras High Court delivered a nuanced ruling that resolved both questions separately. On the first issue, the Court ruled in favour of the soldier, holding that Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016 expressly permits serving Armed Forces personnel due to complete their engagement within one year from the last date of application to apply under the Ex-Servicemen category. However, on the second issue, the Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that where a TNPSC Recruitment Notification explicitly mandates that an Equivalence Certificate must have been issued on or before the date of the notification, a subsequent Equivalence Government Order—here, G.O.(Ms).No.130 dated 24 July 2024—cannot cure the candidate's ineligibility as of the 2022 notification date.

This decision provides critical guidance for defence veterans, TNPSC aspirants, and service-law practitioners reading https://sklawhouse.com/posts: statutory ESM concessions under Section 63(2) are fully enforceable, yet strict compliance with cut-off clauses in recruitment notifications has the force of statute and cannot be relaxed under Article 226 unless the notification condition itself is challenged.

2. DETAILED FACTUAL MATRIX & PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The petitioner, Eswaran, a resident of Sengalanoor Village, Sholinghur Taluk, Ranipet District, was serving in the Indian Army under the Madras Engineering Group and held a Trade Proficiency Certificate in Survey—specifically Regimental Surveyor Technical (RST) Class IV to Class I—issued by the Officer-in-Charge, Demob Battery, Artillery Centre, Nasik Road Camp, Maharashtra. On 29 July 2022, TNPSC issued Notification No. 18/2022 inviting applications for recruitment to the posts of Field Surveyor, Draftsman, and Surveyor-cum-Assistant Draughtsman, followed by a supplemental Notification No. 18A/2023 dated 14 February 2023.

On the date of Notification No. 18/2022 (29 July 2022), Eswaran was 45 years old and was still actively serving in the Indian Army. He was scheduled for discharge on 31 December 2022—well within one year of the notification. Applying under the Ex-Servicemen (ESM) category (where the maximum age limit was 50 years, compared to 32–37 years for general/MBC candidates), he appeared for the written examination conducted on 6 November 2022. Subsequently, he was discharged from military service on 31 December 2022.

When TNPSC proceeded to physical certificate verification, the petitioner's candidature was not included on two grounds: (i) he was still in military service on the notification date and written examination date, and (ii) his Army Trade Proficiency Certificate in Regimental Surveyor Technical had not been declared equivalent to the National Trade Certificate in the Trade of Surveyor awarded by the National Council for Vocational Training (NCVT) as on the date of notification. Aggrieved, Eswaran filed W.P. No. 7752 of 2023 seeking a Writ of Mandamus directing TNPSC to include his name in the physical certificate verification process under the Ex-Servicemen category.

During the pendency of the writ petition, the High Court suo motu impleaded the President, Technical Testing Board, Madras Engineering Group and Centre, Bangalore (R3), and the Officer-in-Charge, Demob Battery, Artillery Centre, Nasik Road Camp (R4) on 6 April 2023, and the Chairman / Secretary to Government, Higher Education Department (R5) on 13 April 2023. Eventually, on 24 July 2024, the Higher Education (K1) Department issued G.O.(Ms).No.130 declaring that the Regimental Surveyor Technical (RST) Class IV to Class I certificate offered by Demob Battery, Artillery Centre, Nasik Road is equivalent to the NCVT National Trade Certificate in Surveyor for public employment. The petitioner also amended his writ prayer on 16 October 2026 to cover all three posts—Field Surveyor, Draftsman, and Surveyor-cum-Assistant Draughtsman. Despite securing the 2024 Equivalence GO, TNPSC maintained that the equivalence came nearly two years after the July 2022 notification cut-off.

3. ISSUES FRAMED & RIVAL SUBMISSIONS

The Madras High Court distilled the dispute into two clear legal issues:

  1. Ex-Servicemen Eligibility of Serving Personnel: Whether an Armed Forces member who is still in service on the date of a TNPSC notification and written examination, but due to be discharged within one year, is eligible to claim age concession and reservation under the Ex-Servicemen quota under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016.
  2. Cut-Off Date for Equivalence Certificate: Whether an Equivalence Government Order issued on 24 July 2024 (G.O.(Ms).No.130) can be applied retrospectively to validate a candidate's qualification for a TNPSC notification dated 29 July 2022 when the notification expressly requires equivalence prior to the notification date.

Submissions on Behalf of the Petitioner

Mr. A. Gokulakrishnan, learned counsel for the petitioner, argued that under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, a person serving in the Armed Forces who is due to complete their engagement within one year from the last date for receipt of applications is legally eligible to apply as an Ex-Servicemen candidate. Since the petitioner was discharged on 31 December 2022—within five months of the 29 July 2022 notification—TNPSC could not disqualify him as an in-service soldier.

On the second limb, counsel contended that once the Higher Education Department issued G.O.(Ms).No.130 dated 24 July 2024 recognizing the equivalence of the petitioner's Army survey certificate with the NCVT National Trade Certificate, that recognition relates back to the date on which the qualification was originally acquired. He relied heavily on the Full Bench judgment of the Madras High Court in Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman A. v. State of Tamil Nadu, 2014 (3) CTC 433, which held that an equivalence certificate merely declares an existing state of equivalence and operates retrospectively. Since the recruitment was made subject to the outcome of the writ petition, he urged the Court to direct TNPSC to consider his candidature.

Submissions on Behalf of TNPSC

Mr. B. Vijay, learned Standing Counsel for TNPSC (R1 and R2), vehemently opposed the petition on three grounds. First, he argued that on the date of the notification (29 July 2022) and the written examination (6 November 2022), the petitioner was still serving in the Army and was 45 years old—far above the 37-year maximum age limit for MBC candidates—and therefore could not be treated as an Ex-Serviceman, relying on the Supreme Court decision in Sudhir Singh v. State of U.P., [2023] 14 SCR 135, and Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2013) 11 SCC 58. He added that the notification itself did not reproduce the Section 63(2) explanation, and having participated without challenging the notification, the petitioner had acquiesced.

Second, on the Equivalence Certificate, Mr. Vijay pointed to the express clause under Educational Qualification in Notification No. 18/2022 stipulating that any Equivalence Certificate must have been issued by the Government on or before the date of the Recruitment Notification. Since G.O.(Ms).No.130 was issued on 24 July 2024—two years after the notification—it could not satisfy the mandatory condition, which carries the force of statute. Third, he submitted that the petitioner had not uploaded the relevant application documents properly. In support, he cited State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalatha, (2020) 19 SCC 430; P. Prabu v. TNPSC (W.A.No.4318 of 2019); B. Lalitha v. Secretary to Government (W.P.Nos.27754 & 23316 of 2021); and John Xaavieer v. The Chairman (W.P.(MD)Nos.4931, 5215 & 5375 of 2023, dated 27.09.2024).

4. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK & PRECEDENT ANALYSIS

Two distinct statutory regimes collided in this dispute. First, Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016 explicitly creates a statutory deeming concession for Armed Forces personnel nearing retirement: persons serving in the Armed Forces are eligible to apply for posts under the State Government if they are due to complete their specified term of engagement within one year from the last date prescribed for receipt of applications, provided they submit a self-undertaking and a Commanding Officer's certificate in Schedule-XII format. Unlike general service rules examined by the Supreme Court in Sudhir Singh v. State of U.P.—where the applicable rules contained no provision deeming serving personnel as Ex-Servicemen—Tamil Nadu's 2016 Act expressly grants that right, and Column 5.A(ii)(a) of TNPSC's own notification cited Section 63 and G.O.(Ms).No.91 dated 13 September 2021.

Second, however, recruitment notifications issued by Public Service Commissions are governed by strict constitutional principles of equality under Articles 14 and 16. In State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalatha, (2020) 19 SCC 430 (Paragraph 8), the Supreme Court held that instructions issued by a Public Service Commission are mandatory, have the force of law, and cannot be modified or relaxed by the High Court under Article 226. Similarly, in Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan, (2011) 12 SCC 85, the Supreme Court emphasized that selection processes must strictly adhere to advertised cut-off dates and conditions, because relaxing a requirement for one candidate would be unfair to countless others who did not apply believing themselves ineligible.

While the Full Bench of the Madras High Court in Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman (2014 (3) CTC 433) established the general rule that equivalence orders relate back to the date of obtaining the degree, subsequent decisions—such as John Xaavieer (W.P.(MD)No.4931 of 2023)—clarified that where the Recruitment Notification itself contains an unchallenged cut-off clause requiring the Equivalence GO to have been issued on or before the notification date, the candidate is estopped from invoking retrospective equivalence unless that notification condition is struck down.

Detailed Comparison: Section 63(2) of the 2016 Act vs. General Central Rules

A major contribution of Justice C. Kumarappan's judgment in Eswaran v. The Secretary, TNPSC (2026:MHC:4518) lies in how it harmonizes Tamil Nadu's statutory Ex-Servicemen concession with Supreme Court precedent. When TNPSC relied on Sudhir Singh v. State of U.P. ([2023] 14 SCR 135) and Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) ((2013) 11 SCC 58) to argue that a soldier in active service on the notification date cannot claim Ex-Servicemen status, the Court carefully examined the statutory text. In Sudhir Singh, the applicable Uttar Pradesh rules contained no deeming provision permitting serving soldiers nearing discharge to apply as Ex-Servicemen. By contrast, Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016—enacted by the Tamil Nadu Legislature—explicitly bridges the transition period for military personnel by allowing those due to complete their engagement within one year from the last date of application to compete under the Ex-Servicemen category, subject to submitting a self-undertaking and Commanding Officer certificate in Schedule-XII.

Furthermore, TNPSC's own Notification No. 18/2022 dated 29 July 2022 expressly incorporated Section 63 of the 2016 Act and G.O.(Ms).No.91, Human Resources Management (S) Department, dated 13 September 2021 under Column 5.A(ii)(a) granting the 50-year maximum age limit to Ex-Servicemen. Therefore, TNPSC could not disown its own statutory framework to disqualify Eswaran (who was discharged on 31 December 2022, just five months after the notification) on the ground of active service.

Why Equivalence Certificates Face Strict Cut-Off Enforcement

Despite winning on the Ex-Servicemen point, the petitioner lost on the Equivalence Certificate point because of a critical procedural distinction. Under Tamil Nadu recruitment law, Equivalence Committees constituted by the Higher Education Department periodically evaluate whether degrees, diplomas, or military trade certificates (such as the Regimental Surveyor Technical Class IV to Class I certificate from Demob Battery, Artillery Centre, Nasik Road) are equivalent to prescribed civilian qualifications (such as the NCVT National Trade Certificate in Surveyor). Where a recruitment notification is silent on the cut-off date for equivalence, the Full Bench ruling in Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman A. v. State of Tamil Nadu (2014 (3) CTC 433) permits a subsequent Equivalence GO to relate back to the date the qualification was earned.

However, learning from prior litigation, TNPSC inserted an explicit condition under 'Educational Qualification' in Notification No. 18/2022 requiring that any Equivalence Certificate must have been issued by the Government on or before the date of the Recruitment Notification (29 July 2022). Following the Supreme Court's mandate in State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalatha ((2020) 19 SCC 430) and Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan ((2011) 12 SCC 85), such notification clauses carry the force of law. Because Eswaran participated without challenging that cut-off clause and obtained G.O.(Ms).No.130 only on 24 July 2024, he was estopped from claiming retrospective equivalence.

5. JUDICIAL REASONING & OPERATIVE DIRECTIONS

Justice C. Kumarappan began by rejecting TNPSC's preliminary objection regarding the petitioner's Ex-Servicemen status. Quoting Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, and reading it harmoniously with Column 5.A(ii)(a) of Notification No. 18/2022, the Court held that the notification disclosed nothing contrary to Section 63. Because the petitioner was due to be discharged within 12 months of the notification (and was in fact discharged on 31 December 2022), his claim for age concession and consideration under the Ex-Servicemen quota was entirely valid and well-merited. Thus, Sudhir Singh was held inapplicable in Tamil Nadu in light of Section 63(2).

However, the petitioner's case failed decisively on the second issue—the cut-off date for the Equivalence Certificate. The Court noted the undisputed timeline: Notification No. 18/2022 was issued on 29 July 2022, the written examination was held on 6 November 2022, and G.O.(Ms).No.130 recognizing equivalence for the Army's Regimental Surveyor Technical certificate was issued only on 24 July 2024. Crucially, Notification No. 18/2022 expressly stipulated under Educational Qualification that any Equivalence Certificate must have been issued by the Government on or before the date of the Recruitment Notification, and the petitioner had never challenged that clause.

Applying the Supreme Court's binding ratio in G. Hemalatha (2020) 19 SCC 430 and Bedanga Talukdar (2011) 12 SCC 85, as well as the co-ordinate ruling in John Xaavieer (W.P.(MD)No.4931 of 2023), Justice Kumarappan held that the stipulation in the Recruitment Notification carried the force of statute. Having participated under those terms without challenging the cut-off clause, the petitioner was estopped from relying on Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman to claim retrospective benefit from G.O.(Ms).No.130 dated 24 July 2024. Accordingly, W.P. No. 7752 of 2023 was dismissed without costs, and connected miscellaneous petitions were closed.

Practical Checklist for Defence Personnel Transitioning to Tamil Nadu Public Services

The twin holdings in Eswaran v. The Secretary, TNPSC (2026:MHC:4518)—affirming Section 63(2) Ex-Servicemen eligibility for soldiers within twelve months of discharge while enforcing the pre-notification Equivalence Certificate cut-off—offer an essential compliance roadmap for Armed Forces personnel preparing for TNPSC Group-I, Group-II, Group-IV, and technical recruitments such as Field Surveyor and Draftsman:

  • Verify Equivalence GOs Before Submitting Online Applications: Never assume that a military trade proficiency certificate (whether in Survey, Mechanical, Signals, or Medical Corps) will automatically be accepted as equivalent to an NCVT/ITI or Polytechnic diploma. Check the Tamil Nadu Higher Education Department's published Equivalence GOs—such as G.O.(Ms).No.130 dated 24 July 2024—before the recruitment notification closes. If no Equivalence GO exists, submit a representation to the Equivalence Committee well in advance of upcoming notifications.
  • Inspect the Exact Wording of the Recruitment Notification: Under State of Tamil Nadu v. G. Hemalatha ((2020) 19 SCC 430), every clause in a TNPSC notification carries statutory force. If the notification mandates that Equivalence Certificates must have been issued on or before the notification date, participating without challenging that clause creates an estoppel.
  • Execute Schedule-XII Undertaking & Commanding Officer Certificate Accurately: Serving soldiers within one year of discharge must ensure their Commanding Officer issues the discharge-window certificate strictly in the Schedule-XII format prescribed under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, and upload all required annexures cleanly on the TNPSC One-Time Registration (OTR) portal.

6. PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS FOR TAMIL NADU LITIGANTS & ADVOCATES

  • Armed Forces Personnel Within 12 Months of Discharge Can Apply: Serving soldiers, sailors, and airmen in Tamil Nadu who are within one year of completing their engagement can lawfully apply for TNPSC posts under the Ex-Servicemen quota by attaching the Schedule-XII Commanding Officer certificate and self-undertaking under Section 63(2) of the 2016 Act.
  • Secure Equivalence GOs Before Notification Dates: Defence personnel holding specialized military trade certificates (such as Army Survey, Engineering, or Medical trades) should verify well in advance whether the Tamil Nadu Higher Education Department has already issued an Equivalence GO equating their trade certificate to civilian ITI/NCVT/diploma qualifications.
  • Challenge Restrictive Notification Clauses Early: If a TNPSC notification bars equivalence orders issued after the notification date, a candidate relying on the Full Bench ruling in Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman must specifically challenge that restrictive clause by way of Certiorari before participating, rather than seeking a bare Mandamus after failing certificate verification.
  • Prospective Benefit of G.O.(Ms).No.130: While Eswaran could not obtain relief for the 2022 recruitment, G.O.(Ms).No.130 dated 24 July 2024 now stands as a valid, published Equivalence Order for all future TNPSC Surveyor recruitments conducted after 24 July 2024.

For further updates on TNPSC recruitment litigation, Ex-Servicemen service rights, and Madras High Court judgments, visit https://sklawhouse.com/posts or reach out via https://sklawhouse.com/contact-us.

Summary of Judicial Holdings in Eswaran v. TNPSC

In sum, Eswaran v. The Secretary, TNPSC (2026:MHC:4518) establishes a clear dual-track rule for Tamil Nadu public recruitment: Section 63(2) of the 2016 Act robustly protects serving Armed Forces personnel scheduled for discharge within twelve months, preventing TNPSC from disqualifying them as in-service soldiers; simultaneously, unchallenged notification clauses fixing the date of the recruitment notification as the deadline for Equivalence Certificates operate with statutory force and cannot be bypassed via retrospective Equivalence GOs issued years later.

7. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)

Can a soldier still serving in the Indian Army apply under the Ex-Servicemen quota in TNPSC exams?

Yes. Under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, a serving Armed Forces member who is due to be discharged within one year from the last date for application is eligible to apply under the Ex-Servicemen category by submitting a self-undertaking and Schedule-XII Commanding Officer certificate.

Why did the Madras High Court dismiss Eswaran's writ petition despite G.O.(Ms).No.130?

Because TNPSC Notification No. 18/2022 (dated 29 July 2022) explicitly required that any Equivalence Certificate be issued on or before the notification date, and G.O.(Ms).No.130 was issued nearly two years later on 24 July 2024. Since the petitioner never challenged that notification clause, it operated with statutory force against him.

Does the Full Bench ruling in Nadar Thanga Shubha Laxman allow retrospective equivalence in every TNPSC case?

No. As clarified in Eswaran v. TNPSC (2026:MHC:4518), where the recruitment notification itself contains an unchallenged stipulation requiring the equivalence order to predate the notification, the High Court cannot relax that condition under Article 226.

Is the Army's Regimental Surveyor Technical certificate now equivalent to NCVT Surveyor in Tamil Nadu?

Yes, for recruitments notified on or after 24 July 2024, G.O.(Ms).No.130, Higher Education (K1) Department, recognizes the Regimental Surveyor Technical (RST) Class IV to Class I certificate from Demob Battery, Artillery Centre, Nasik Road as equivalent to the NCVT National Trade Certificate in Surveyor.

What documents must a serving soldier attach when applying under Section 63(2) of the 2016 Act?

Under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, a serving Armed Forces member due for discharge within one year must submit a self-undertaking and a certificate from their Commanding Officer in the format prescribed in Schedule-XII.

What is the maximum age limit for Ex-Servicemen in TNPSC recruitments like Field Surveyor?

As noted in Column 5.A(ii)(a) of TNPSC Notification No. 18/2022, the maximum age limit for Ex-Servicemen ('Others') is 50 years, compared to 32–37 years for general/MBC categories.

Can TNPSC reject a candidate who was discharged five months after the recruitment notification?

No, not on that ground alone. Under Section 63(2) of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016, serving Armed Forces personnel due for discharge within one year from the application deadline are eligible under the Ex-Servicemen quota.

SK Law House on WhatsApp Latest judgments and legal updates Join channel
Stay updated instantly

Turn on notifications for legal updates, new articles, and important office alerts.

Get email updates too

Receive legal articles, important notices, and office updates in your inbox.

Office enquiry

Send a brief enquiry for office follow-up. Please keep confidential documents for a private discussion.

WhatsApp