Skip to main content

SK Law House Legal Articles

Law updates, legal guidance, and practical articles for clients and readers of `sklawhouse.com`.

2026-11-18 21:54:12

NHAI Landowners Entitled to Solatium and Interest Under Tarsem Singh Without Filing Section 3G(5) Arbitration: Madurai Bench

Court category: High Court

Court / details: Madras High Court (Madurai Bench)

Location: Dindigul / Madurai, Tamil Nadu

In A. Saroja v. Special District Revenue Officer, Dindigul (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026), the Madurai Bench held that landowners whose NHAI awards were passed between 1997 and 2014 can seek statutory solatium and interest via Article 226 writ without filing Section 3G(5) arbitration, applying Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291).

CASE DETAILS AT A GLANCE

  • Case Title: A. Saroja v. The Special District Revenue Officer (Land Acquisition, National Highways), Dindigul & Another
  • Case Number: W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026
  • Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras (Madurai Bench)
  • Bench: The Hon'ble Mr. Justice S. Sounthar
  • Reserved On / Pronounced On: 28 September 2026 / 16 October 2026
  • Counsel for Petitioner: M/s. A. Hariharan
  • Counsel for Respondent No. 1 (SDRO): Mrs. K. Porkodi, Special Government Pleader
  • Counsel for Respondent No. 2 (NHAI): Mr. P. Karthick, Standing Counsel
  • Key Provisions & Precedents: Sections 3A(1), 3G(5), and 3J of the National Highways Act, 1956; Sections 23(2) & 28 proviso, Land Acquisition Act, 1894; Article 14, Article 226, and Article 300-A of the Constitution; Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, (2019) 9 SCC 304 (Tarsem I); AIR 2025 SCC 1460 (Tarsem II); NHAI v. Tarsem Singh, 2026 INSC 291 (Tarsem III); Manav Bhanot v. NHAI, 2026 INSC 973; Etti Gounder v. District Collector, 2021 (6) CTC 618; Baba John v. Competent Authority (W.A.Nos.1064 & 1170 of 2026)

1. EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW & LEGAL SIGNIFICANCE

Thousands of landowners in Tamil Nadu whose agricultural or residential lands were acquired between 1997 and 31 December 2014 for National Highways expansion—such as NH-45, NH-47, and NH-7—received bare market-value awards without the statutory 30% solatium and statutory interest, because Section 3J of the National Highways Act, 1956 excluded the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Even after the Supreme Court struck down Section 3J as unconstitutional in Union of India v. Tarsem Singh (2019) 9 SCC 304, Competent Authorities (Special District Revenue Officers) across Tamil Nadu routinely rejected landowners' representations for solatium and interest on two technical objections: that the landowner failed to challenge the original award before the District Collector-cum-Arbitrator under Section 3G(5), or that the claim was belated.

In A. Saroja v. The Special District Revenue Officer, Dindigul (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026), pronounced on 16 October 2026, Justice S. Sounthar of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court delivered a landmark synthesis of the Supreme Court's entire Tarsem Singh trilogy—including the latest 2026 ruling in NHAI v. Tarsem Singh (2026 INSC 291, Tarsem III) and Manav Bhanot v. NHAI (2026 INSC 973)—alongside the First Bench decision in Baba John (W.A.Nos.1064 & 1170 of 2026). The Court held that because solatium and interest are mandatory statutory constants arising directly from constitutional jurisprudence, a landowner is fully entitled to maintain a writ petition under Article 226 without having filed an arbitration claim under Section 3G(5). Applying Direction (ii) of Tarsem III, the Court balanced delay by awarding interest and interest on solatium from the date of the landowner's representation (23 August 2024) until actual payment (15 September 2026), directing disbursal within six weeks.

For landowners and advocates following land acquisition updates on https://sklawhouse.com/posts, this judgment provides a crystal-clear roadmap for recovering statutory solatium and interest in pre-2015 NHAI acquisitions.

2. DETAILED FACTUAL MATRIX & PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The petitioner, A. Saroja, owned 1 acre and 46 cents in Survey No. 735/4, Seelappadi Village, Dindigul Taluk, Dindigul District, under a sale deed dated 17 September 1984 and Patta No. 1072. For the expansion of National Highway No. 45, the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) acquired two portions of her land through separate notifications under Section 3A(1) of the National Highways Act, 1956. Under the first notification dated 13 September 2007, 777 sq. metres were acquired, and the Special District Revenue Officer (SDRO, Land Acquisition) passed an award on 15 July 2009 fixing compensation at Rs. 4,13,999/-. Under a second notification dated 8 August 2008, another 267 sq. metres were acquired, and a second award was passed on 1 December 2009 fixing compensation at Rs. 1,42,262/-.

However, neither award amount (totaling Rs. 5,56,261/-) was paid to Saroja or deposited in Court. According to the SDRO, during title verification after the 2009 awards, a third-party objection dated 22 June 2010 citing a pending civil suit was received. That civil suit was finally decided only on 13 March 2023, and the decree was registered on 27 June 2024.

Following resolution of the civil dispute, Saroja submitted a representation dated 23 August 2024 to the SDRO seeking payment of the award amounts along with solatium, interest, and interest on solatium in terms of Tarsem Singh (2019) 9 SCC 304 and Etti Gounder, 2021 (6) CTC 618. When the SDRO failed to act, she filed W.P.(MD) No. 25515 of 2024, wherein the High Court directed consideration of her representation. Only after she issued a contempt notice did the SDRO pass the impugned order in Na.Ka.No. 216/2026/A3 dated 28 April 2026—directing payment of the bare award principal while rejecting her claim for solatium and interest and advising her to approach the District Collector under Section 3G(5) for any enhancement. Challenging that rejection, she filed W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026. During its pendency, pursuant to an interim direction, the principal award amount of Rs. 5,56,261/- was finally credited to her bank account on 15 September 2026.

3. ISSUES FRAMED & RIVAL SUBMISSIONS

Justice S. Sounthar adjudicated three intertwined legal issues:

  1. Maintainability Without Section 3G(5) Arbitration: Whether a landowner who did not seek arbitration before the District Collector under Section 3G(5) of the National Highways Act can claim solatium, interest, and interest on solatium directly through a representation and Article 226 writ petition.
  2. Eligibility Under Tarsem Singh I, II & III Cut-Off Rules: Whether a landowner whose awards were passed in July and December 2009 (after 28 March 2008), but who first claimed solatium and interest on 23 August 2024, is barred by delay or entitled from the date of representation.
  3. Liability for Interest on Delayed Payment: Whether NHAI and the Competent Authority can deny interest when the principal award of Rs. 5,56,261/- remained unpaid from 2009 until 15 September 2026.

Submissions on Behalf of the Petitioner

M/s. A. Hariharan, counsel for Saroja, relied on the complete line of Supreme Court and Madras High Court precedents—Tarsem Singh I ((2019) 9 SCC 304), Tarsem Singh II (AIR 2025 SCC 1460), Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291), Etti Gounder (2021 (6) CTC 618), Baba John (W.A.Nos.1064 & 1170 of 2026), and Abbas T. Vagh (2014 (1) CWC 1)—to submit that solatium and interest are automatic statutory entitlements under Article 300-A that the SDRO was bound to calculate without forcing the landowner into Section 3G(5) arbitration.

Submissions on Behalf of the SDRO and NHAI

Mrs. K. Porkodi, Special Government Pleader for the SDRO, argued that the delay in payment was caused by the third-party civil suit (2010–2023), that Saroja never filed a Section 3G(5) arbitration claim, and that her belated demand was barred under the Division Bench ruling in M. Sapabathi v. District Collector, 2026 MHC 3258. Mr. P. Karthick, Standing Counsel for NHAI, argued that the National Highways Act contains no provision analogous to Section 34 of the 1894 Act for interest on delayed payment, and contended that Saroja's claim was not alive on the 28 March 2008 cut-off date.

4. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK & PRECEDENT ANALYSIS

Justice S. Sounthar traced the legislative arc of National Highways acquisitions across three eras: (i) pre-1997 acquisitions under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (which included solatium and interest); (ii) the 1997–31.12.2014 interregnum under amended Sections 3A–3J of the National Highways Act, where Section 3J excluded the 1894 Act; and (iii) acquisitions from 1 January 2015 onwards, where the Right to Fair Compensation Act, 2013 applies automatically. For the 1997–2014 interregnum, the Supreme Court in Tarsem Singh I (read with NHAI v. Tehal Singh, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 3175) struck down Section 3J under Article 14 and applied Section 23(2) (30% solatium) and Section 28 proviso (interest) of the 1894 Act. In Tarsem Singh II (AIR 2025 SCC 1460), the Supreme Court held that Tarsem I operates retrospectively because solatium and interest are integral to Article 300-A.

Crucially, in Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291), the Supreme Court laid down three binding rules on delay: (i) landowners whose compensation claims were alive on or after 28 March 2008 before any prescribed forum are entitled to solatium, interest, and interest on solatium; (ii) where the claim was alive on 28 March 2008, but solatium/interest was claimed belatedly after 28 March 2008, no interest is payable for the delay period—interest and interest on solatium run only from the date the claim was raised; and (iii) claims concluded prior to 28 March 2008 cannot be reopened.

Further, citing Etti Gounder (2021 (6) CTC 618)—as affirmed by the First Bench in Baba John (W.A.Nos.1064 & 1170 of 2026)—the Court reiterated that solatium and interest are statutory constants outside the Arbitrator's discretion, making an Article 226 writ maintainable without invoking Section 3G(5) or Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. Finally, citing Kolkata Municipal Corporation v. Bimal Kumar Shah, (2024) 10 SCC 533, and Manav Bhanot v. NHAI, 2026 INSC 973, the Court affirmed that withholding interest despite years of inflation denies fair compensation under Article 300-A.

Complete Timeline of NHAI Solatium Jurisprudence (1997 to 2026)

Justice S. Sounthar's judgment in A. Saroja v. The Special District Revenue Officer, Dindigul (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026) provides a comprehensive road map of nearly three decades of National Highways compensation jurisprudence:

  1. Pre-1997 Regime: Acquisitions for National Highways were governed by the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, under which landowners automatically received 30% solatium (Section 23(2)) and statutory interest (Section 28 proviso).
  2. 1997 Amendment & Section 3J Exclusion: In 1997, Sections 3A to 3J were inserted into the National Highways Act, 1956, and Section 3J expressly excluded the 1894 Act—depriving landowners acquired between 1997 and 31 December 2014 of solatium and interest.
  3. Post-2015 Regime: Effective 1 January 2015, the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was extended to National Highways acquisitions, restoring 100% solatium and statutory interest prospectively.
  4. Tarsem Singh I (2019) & Tehal Singh (2021): In Union of India v. Tarsem Singh, (2019) 9 SCC 304 (as modified in NHAI v. Tehal Singh, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 3175), the Supreme Court declared Section 3J unconstitutional under Article 14 and extended Section 23(2) solatium and Section 28 proviso interest to 1997–2014 NHAI acquisitions.
  5. Tarsem Singh II (2025): In AIR 2025 SCC 1460, the Supreme Court rejected NHAI's plea for prospective application, holding that solatium and interest form an integral part of fair compensation under Article 300-A.
  6. Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291) & Manav Bhanot (2026 INSC 973): In 2026, the Supreme Court settled the cut-off date of 28 March 2008 for pending claims and clarified that even where an award was passed prior to 1 January 2015, solatium, interest, and interest on solatium must be computed under the 1894 Act—while limiting interest in belatedly raised claims to run from the date the claim was raised.

Why Third-Party Civil Suits Do Not Excuse Non-Deposit of Compensation

A noteworthy aspect of A. Saroja is the State's attempt to blame the 17-year delay (2009 to 2026) on a third-party civil suit pending between 2010 and 2023. Under settled land acquisition law, when a title dispute arises after an award is passed, the Competent Authority is legally required to deposit the compensation amount in the jurisdictional Civil Court rather than retaining it indefinitely in government accounts. Because the SDRO neither paid Saroja nor deposited the Rs. 5,56,261/- award until 15 September 2026—and because inflation over 17 years severely eroded the real value of the 2009 award—denying interest would violate Article 300-A as explained in Kolkata Municipal Corporation v. Bimal Kumar Shah ((2024) 10 SCC 533) and Abbas T. Vagh (2014 (1) CWC 1).

5. JUDICIAL REASONING & OPERATIVE DIRECTIONS

Applying Tarsem III to Saroja's timeline, Justice S. Sounthar rejected NHAI's cut-off objection: because the two awards were passed on 15 July 2009 and 1 December 2009—well after 28 March 2008—her compensation determination was actively pending before the Competent Authority on the cut-off date of 28 March 2008. Distinguishing M. Sapabathi (2026 MHC 3258) on the ground that Tarsem III specifically governs how delay is treated, the Court applied Direction (ii) of Tarsem III: Saroja was not entitled to interest for the period prior to her representation, but was squarely entitled to interest and interest on solatium from the date of her representation (23 August 2024) until the date of actual payment of the principal award (15 September 2026), in addition to statutory solatium.

Allowing W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026 without costs, the Madurai Bench directed the Special District Revenue Officer (LA-NH), Dindigul, to calculate the applicable solatium, interest, and interest on solatium for the period from 23 August 2024 to 15 September 2026 in terms of Tarsem Singh III and disburse the entire amount to the petitioner within six weeks from receipt of a copy of the order.

Step-by-Step Guide for Tamil Nadu NHAI Landowners Claiming Solatium & Interest Under A. Saroja

Landowners across Tamil Nadu—including Dindigul, Trichy, Madurai, Villupuram, Vellore, Krishnagiri, Salem, and Tiruvannamalai—whose lands were acquired for National Highways expansion between 1997 and 31 December 2014 can follow this structured legal roadmap based on A. Saroja v. SDRO, Dindigul (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026) and Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291):

  1. Verify Acquisition & Award Dates: Locate the Section 3A(1) preliminary notification, Section 3D declaration, and the Competent Authority's Award under Section 3G. Confirm that the award was passed before 1 January 2015 and that your compensation claim was alive on or after 28 March 2008 (either because the award itself was passed on or after 28 March 2008, as in Saroja's 2009 awards, or because a Section 3G(5) arbitration, Section 34 petition, or writ was pending on 28 March 2008).
  2. Audit Earlier Disbursement Vouchers: Check whether the award paid only the basic market value of land/trees/structures or already included 30% solatium under Section 23(2) of the 1894 Act and 9%/15% statutory interest under Section 28 proviso.
  3. Submit a Formal Representation Immediately: Address a detailed written representation via RPAD to the Special District Revenue Officer (Land Acquisition, National Highways) and the NHAI Project Director, citing Tarsem Singh I, II, and III (2026 INSC 291), Manav Bhanot v. NHAI (2026 INSC 973), Etti Gounder (2021 (6) CTC 618), and A. Saroja (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026). Remember that under Direction (ii) of Tarsem III, interest on belated claims begins running from the date of your written representation.
  4. File an Article 226 Writ Petition if Rejected or Ignored: If the SDRO rejects the claim citing non-filing of Section 3G(5) arbitration or keeps it pending, file a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus before the Madras High Court or Madurai Bench seeking a time-bound direction (typically six weeks) for computation and disbursal.

Distinguishing Statutory Solatium From Market-Value Enhancement

A recurring confusion among revenue officers is treating solatium and statutory interest as 'enhanced compensation' requiring Section 3G(5) arbitration before the District Collector. As Etti Gounder, Baba John, and A. Saroja make clear, market-value enhancement (challenging the per-cent or per-sq.ft. rate) lies within the Arbitrator's domain under Section 3G(5), whereas 30% solatium and Section 28 interest are mandatory statutory constants flowing automatically from the Constitution and Parliament's 1894 Act formula—leaving zero discretion with the SDRO.

6. PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS FOR TAMIL NADU LITIGANTS & ADVOCATES

  • Check the 28 March 2008 Cut-Off Date: If your NHAI acquisition award was passed on or after 28 March 2008 (or an appeal/arbitration/writ was pending on that date) and before 1 January 2015, you remain eligible for solatium and interest under Tarsem III (2026 INSC 291).
  • Submit a Written Representation Immediately: Because interest and interest on solatium run from the date of your written claim where there was prior delay, filing a formal representation immediately stops further loss of interest.
  • Do Not Be Deterred by Absence of Section 3G(5) Arbitration: Following A. Saroja, Etti Gounder, and Baba John, the SDRO cannot reject solatium/interest claims merely because no arbitration petition was filed before the District Collector.
  • Challenge Unfair Rejections Under Article 226: If the SDRO refuses statutory solatium or interest, an Article 226 writ petition before the Madras High Court or Madurai Bench is maintainable directly.

For legal support on National Highways land acquisition compensation and solatium claims in Tamil Nadu, visit https://sklawhouse.com/posts or contact https://sklawhouse.com/contact-us.

Interest Computation Parameters Under Section 28 Proviso of the 1894 Act

When the Special District Revenue Officer (LA-NH), Dindigul, or any Competent Authority across Tamil Nadu computes arrears pursuant to A. Saroja (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026) and Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291), the statutory components follow the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 formula as affirmed in Manav Bhanot v. NHAI (2026 INSC 973): first, 30% solatium under Section 23(2) on the market value determined in the award; second, statutory interest under the proviso to Section 28 (9% per annum for the first year and 15% per annum thereafter) on both the unpaid award principal and the solatium component—strictly restricted, in belated-claim cases under Direction (ii) of Tarsem III, to the period running from the date of the landowner's written representation (here, 23 August 2024) until the date of actual payment (15 September 2026). Landowners and advocates should independently verify the SDRO's calculation sheet against these exact dates before signing final satisfaction receipts.

Significance of the First Bench Affirmation in Baba John (2026)

By relying on the First Bench decision in Baba John and Others v. The Competent Authority, Special District Revenue Officer (LA), Vellore (W.A.Nos.1064 & 1170 of 2026) alongside Etti Gounder (2021 (6) CTC 618), Justice S. Sounthar's order in A. Saroja removes the last remaining procedural excuse used by Competent Authorities across Tamil Nadu to deny NHAI solatium claims. Because Section 3J was struck down as unconstitutional and solatium and interest are mandatory statutory constants, landowners need not have invoked Section 3G(5) arbitration or Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to recover their constitutional entitlement under Article 300-A.

7. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)

Can NHAI landowners claim solatium and interest without filing arbitration under Section 3G(5)?

Yes. In A. Saroja v. SDRO, Dindigul (W.P.(MD) No. 18735 of 2026), the Madurai Bench reaffirmed that solatium and interest are mandatory statutory constants and an Article 226 writ petition is maintainable even without Section 3G(5) arbitration.

How does Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291) treat delay in claiming NHAI solatium?

Where the compensation claim was alive on 28 March 2008 but solatium/interest was demanded belatedly thereafter, no interest is paid for the delay period; interest and interest on solatium are awarded from the date the written claim/representation was raised until actual payment.

Why did the Court hold Saroja's claim was alive on 28 March 2008?

Because her two NHAI awards were passed on 15 July 2009 and 1 December 2009, meaning her compensation proceedings were pending before the Competent Authority on 28 March 2008.

What timeline did the Madurai Bench fix for payment?

The Court directed the SDRO, Dindigul, to calculate and pay the solatium, interest, and interest on solatium within six weeks of receiving the order copy.

Does a third-party title suit excuse NHAI from paying interest on delayed compensation?

No. Where compensation is neither paid to the landowner nor deposited in Court for years, withholding interest diminishes the real value of compensation due to inflation and violates Article 300-A. Under Tarsem III, however, if the landowner's representation for solatium/interest was submitted belatedly, interest runs from the date of that representation until actual payment.

Why did the Court distinguish M. Sapabathi v. District Collector (2026 MHC 3258)?

Because M. Sapabathi relied on a 2017 Ministry guideline to reject belated claims, whereas A. Saroja applied the binding 2026 Supreme Court directions in Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291) and Etti Gounder, which treat solatium and interest as automatic statutory constants.

What is the exact cut-off date fixed by the Supreme Court in Tarsem Singh III (2026 INSC 291)?

The cut-off date is 28 March 2008. Landowners whose NHAI compensation claims were alive on or after 28 March 2008 before a prescribed forum are entitled to solatium, interest, and interest on solatium, whereas claims finally concluded prior to 28 March 2008 cannot be reopened.

How much solatium is payable for NHAI acquisitions where the award was passed between 1997 and 2014?

Under Section 23(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894—applied to NHAI acquisitions by Tarsem Singh I and Manav Bhanot (2026 INSC 973)—landowners are entitled to 30% solatium on the market value, plus statutory interest under Section 28 proviso and interest on solatium.

Can the SDRO reject a representation under Tarsem Singh simply because 15 years have passed since the 2009 award?

No. Delay does not extinguish entitlement to solatium if the claim was alive on 28 March 2008; under Direction (ii) of Tarsem Singh III, delay only restricts the period of interest to run from the date the written claim was raised.

Does Tarsem Singh III apply to National Highway acquisitions notified under Section 3A(1) after 2015?

No. For NHAI acquisitions where awards or compensation determinations occur on or after 1 January 2015, the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 automatically governs solatium and interest without needing Tarsem Singh.

SK Law House on WhatsApp Latest judgments and legal updates Join channel
Stay updated instantly

Turn on notifications for legal updates, new articles, and important office alerts.

Get email updates too

Receive legal articles, important notices, and office updates in your inbox.

Office enquiry

Send a brief enquiry for office follow-up. Please keep confidential documents for a private discussion.

WhatsApp