Supreme Court Transfers Cross Trademark Suits Between Indore Commercial Court and Delhi High Court to City Civil Court, Ahmedabad
Court category: Supreme Court
Court / details: Supreme Court of India
Location: New Delhi / Ahmedabad / Indore
In M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170), the Supreme Court exercised its transfer jurisdiction to consolidate competing commercial trademark infringement suits pending in Indore and New Delhi before a single neutral forum—the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
CASE DETAILS AT A GLANCE
- Case Title: M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (heard with Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 175 of 2026)
- Case Numbers: Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 3594 of 2025 and Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 175 of 2026
- Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1170
- Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Original Jurisdiction)
- Bench: The Hon'ble Mr. Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and The Hon'ble Mr. Justice N.V. Anjaria
- Date of Decision: 28 October 2026
- Counsel: Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Senior Counsel, and Ms. S. Janani, Senior Counsel, for the parties
- Key Provisions & Subject Matter: Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999; Transfer and consolidation of cross commercial trademark infringement, passing-off, copyright infringement, dilution, and well-known mark suits
1. EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW & LEGAL SIGNIFICANCE
In modern commercial and intellectual property litigation across India, competing corporate entities frequently institute mirror or cross-suits in different High Courts and District Commercial Courts over the same trademark—each seeking to secure home-turf procedural advantage and conflicting interim injunctions. When two commercial suits involving identical parties and overlapping trademark rights proceed simultaneously in two different states, the risk of inconsistent judicial findings, duplicated evidence, and multiplicity of proceedings becomes acute.
In M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170), decided on 28 October 2026, a Bench of the Supreme Court comprising Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria resolved competing Transfer Petitions filed by both corporate rivals. While The Supreme Industries Limited sought transfer of Supremo India's Indore commercial suit to New Delhi, Supremo India sought transfer of Supreme Industries' Delhi High Court suit to Indore. Recognizing that both sides agreed on consolidating the cross-suits before a single court—yet fiercely opposed each other's home forum—the Supreme Court exercised its discretionary transfer jurisdiction to transfer both suits to a neutral third forum: the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad, directing the parties to appear there on 26 November 2026.
For commercial litigators, corporate counsel, and IP practitioners following Supreme Court updates on https://sklawhouse.com/posts, this judgment illustrates the Supreme Court's pragmatic willingness to break forum-shopping deadlocks by selecting a neutral commercial forum rather than rewarding either litigant's preferred jurisdiction.
2. DETAILED FACTUAL MATRIX & PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The dispute arose between two commercial entities—M/s The Supreme Industries Limited and M/s Supremo India Private Limited—over competing rights to the trademark/label 'SUPREME' across physical and virtual e-commerce marketplaces. Both companies instituted parallel commercial suits in 2025 in different jurisdictions:
- The Indore Commercial Suit (CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025): Instituted by M/s Supremo India Private Limited before the Court of the District Judge (Commercial), Indore, Madhya Pradesh, against M/s The Supreme Industries Limited. In its plaint, Supremo India sought: (a) a permanent injunction restraining Supreme Industries from manufacturing, advertising, or dealing in goods bearing the impugned mark 'SUPREME'; (b) restraint against asset disposal and disclosure of assets; (c) takedown and disabling of impugned goods from third-party interactive e-commerce platforms; and (d) damages of Rs. 15,00,000/-.
- The Delhi High Court Commercial Suit (CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025): Instituted by M/s The Supreme Industries Limited before the High Court of Delhi against M/s Supremo India Private Limited and another. Supreme Industries sought broader reliefs: (a) permanent injunction against registered trademark infringement in virtual and physical marketplaces; (b) permanent injunction against passing off; (c) permanent injunction against copyright infringement in the label/logo 'SUPREME'; (d) injunction against dilution and tarnishment of distinctive character; (e) rendition of accounts of profits; (f) delivery-up and destruction of infringing products; (g) damages of Rs. 2,00,01,000/- jointly and severally; and (h) declaration of 'SUPREME' as a well-known trademark under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
To consolidate these competing actions, M/s The Supreme Industries Limited filed Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 3594 of 2025 before the Supreme Court seeking transfer of CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025 from Indore to a competent court at New Delhi. Conversely, M/s Supremo India Private Limited filed Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 175 of 2026 seeking transfer of CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025 from the Delhi High Court to the District Judge (Commercial Court), Indore, Madhya Pradesh.
3. ISSUES FRAMED & RIVAL SUBMISSIONS
The core procedural issue before the Supreme Court was:
- Where both parties to cross commercial trademark infringement suits agree that both suits should be tried together before a single Court, yet each opposes transferring its suit to the rival's chosen forum, how should the Supreme Court exercise its discretionary transfer jurisdiction to ensure expeditious, unbiased adjudication?
Rival Submissions
Appearing for the parties, learned Senior Counsel Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul and Ms. S. Janani each insisted that the opposing party's suit be transferred to the forum where their respective client had instituted its action (New Delhi versus Indore). Crucially, however, both Senior Counsel were ad idem that both commercial suits ought to be tried before a single Court to avoid conflicting decrees, and suggested alternative neutral venues while opposing each other's home court. Both sides left it to the Supreme Court's discretion to select one particular neutral Court to try both matters.
4. STATUTORY FRAMEWORK & PRECEDENT ANALYSIS
Under Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the Supreme Court possesses plenary power, on the application of a party, to direct that any suit, appeal, or other proceeding be transferred from a High Court or other Civil Court in one State to a High Court or other Civil Court in another State whenever it is satisfied that such an order is expedient for the ends of justice.
In commercial and intellectual property disputes—especially those involving e-commerce takedowns, pan-India sales, competing trademark registrations, and claims for well-known mark status under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999—multiplicity of proceedings across two states creates severe procedural hazards. One court might grant an interim injunction while another refuses it, or conflicting findings on prior user and deceptive similarity could paralyze commercial operations. Under settled Section 25 jurisprudence, avoiding conflicting judgments and conserving judicial time are paramount considerations, and the Supreme Court is not bound to pick either party's preferred forum when a neutral third forum serves the ends of justice.
Strategic Dynamics of Cross Commercial IP Suits in India
To appreciate why the Supreme Court's intervention in M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170) is so instructive for commercial practitioners, one must examine the tactical landscape of trademark litigation under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, a registered trademark proprietor can institute an infringement suit in the District Court or High Court where the plaintiff actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business—a statutory departure from the general defendant-centric rule under Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Simultaneously, a rival trader accused of infringement or receiving cease-and-desist notices frequently files a counter-suit or groundless-threat/passing-off action in its own home city, as Supremo India did in Indore (CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025) seeking Rs. 15,00,000/- in damages and restraint against e-commerce takedowns, while Supreme Industries pursued a comprehensive Rs. 2,00,01,000/- suit in the Delhi High Court (CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025) seeking well-known trademark status under Section 2(1)(zg).
When two such cross-suits run on parallel tracks in different States, both courts face identical factual questions: prior adoption and continuous use of the mark 'SUPREME', phonetic and visual similarity, overlap of trade channels across physical and e-commerce platforms, and goodwill/reputation. If Indore and Delhi proceeded separately, witnesses would have to depose twice, e-commerce intermediaries could face contradictory takedown orders, and conflicting decrees on infringement and passing off would create chaos. Under Section 25 CPC, the Supreme Court regularly steps in to consolidate such cross-suits.
Significance of Selecting a Neutral Third Commercial Forum
What sets 2026 INSC 1170 apart is the Supreme Court's refusal to let either party gain a home-turf advantage when both sides are locked in a forum stalemate. Senior Counsel for Supreme Industries pressed for New Delhi, while Senior Counsel for Supremo India pressed for Indore, though both agreed that one Court should try both suits. Rather than conducting a mini-trial on convenience or forum non conveniens at the transfer stage—and explicitly abstaining from any comment on the substantive merits—Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria exercised Section 25 discretion to transfer both CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025 (Indore) and CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025 (Delhi High Court) to the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
For corporate litigants across India, including Tamil Nadu manufacturers and brand owners litigating before the Madras High Court Commercial Division, this precedent confirms two practical realities: first, filing a pre-emptive suit in a distant district court will not automatically pull a High Court commercial suit to that district, and second, the Supreme Court will readily choose a neutral third-state commercial court whenever both parties agree on consolidation but deadlock over venue.
5. JUDICIAL REASONING & OPERATIVE DIRECTIONS
Writing the judgment for the Bench, Justice S.V.N. Bhatti carefully abstained from expressing any opinion on the substantive merits of either party's trademark, copyright, passing-off, or well-known mark claims. Taking note of the consensus between Senior Counsel that both cross-suits should be adjudicated by one Court, and exercising the jurisdiction and discretion vested in the Supreme Court, the Bench issued the following operative directions in Paragraph 6:
- Transfer of Both Suits to Ahmedabad: Both CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025 pending before the District Judge (Commercial), Indore, and CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025 pending before the High Court of Delhi were transferred to the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
- Expeditious Transmission of Plaints: The Courts at Indore and Delhi where the suits were instituted were directed to transfer the respective plaints and records to the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad expeditiously.
- Fixed Appearance Date: Both parties were directed to appear before the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad on 26 November 2026.
- Disposal of Petitions: Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 3594 of 2025 and Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 175 of 2026 were disposed of accordingly, along with all pending applications.
Procedural Mechanics of Section 25 CPC Transfer Petitions in Commercial & IP Disputes
Because M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170) illustrates how the Supreme Court resolves multi-state commercial trademark battles, commercial litigators should understand the exact procedural framework governing Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908:
- Notice & Interim Stay Considerations: When a Transfer Petition (Civil) is filed under Section 25 CPC before the Supreme Court, the petitioner typically seeks an interim stay of proceedings in the out-of-state suit so that conflicting interim injunction applications (under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC) are not decided before the Supreme Court rules on consolidation.
- Distinction From Section 10 CPC (Stay of Subsequent Suit): Parties sometimes attempt to invoke Section 10 CPC before the later-filed court to stay the second suit. However, Section 10 CPC applies only when the matter in issue is directly and substantially identical and the first court has jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed in the second suit. Where one suit is filed in a District Commercial Court (e.g., Indore seeking Rs. 15 lakhs) and the cross-suit is filed in a High Court's Commercial Division (e.g., Delhi seeking Rs. 2,00,01,000/- and well-known mark declaration under Section 2(1)(zg)), Section 10 often triggers protracted jurisdictional objections—making a direct Section 25 Transfer Petition before the Supreme Court far cleaner and faster.
- E-Commerce Marketplace Injunctions & Asset Disclosure: Modern trademark cross-suits routinely target interactive e-commerce listings (seeking takedowns and algorithmic delisting) alongside Mareva-style asset-disclosure prayers. Having two separate courts issue divergent e-commerce takedown directives creates severe operational disruption for manufacturers, distributors, and online platforms—reinforcing why consolidation before one neutral commercial court (such as the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad) serves both justice and commercial certainty.
- Compliance Upon Transfer: Once the Supreme Court directs expeditious transfer of plaints and fixes an appearance date (here, 26 November 2026), both sides must ensure that vakalatnamas, pending Order XXXIX applications, and digital/physical exhibits are coordinated with the transferee court registry without delay, as the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 imposes strict case-management timelines.
Lessons for Corporate Brand Owners and Trade Mark Counsel
For businesses in Chennai, Coimbatore, Tiruppur, and across Tamil Nadu that market products nationally and online under registered trademarks, 2026 INSC 1170 underscores the value of proactive forum management. Before issuing aggressive cease-and-desist notices to competitors in other states, brand owners should evaluate whether their own High Court suit is ready for filing under Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, and be prepared for the Supreme Court to select a neutral commercial venue if cross-suits erupt simultaneously in two jurisdictions.
6. PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS FOR TAMIL NADU LITIGANTS & ADVOCATES
- Consolidate Cross IP Suits Early: Businesses facing simultaneous trademark or copyright suits in two different states (for instance, Chennai and Mumbai/Delhi) should promptly move under Section 25 CPC before the Supreme Court to prevent conflicting interim orders.
- Be Prepared for a Neutral Third Forum: When both parties insist on their respective home jurisdictions, the Supreme Court may transfer both suits to a neutral third commercial centre—such as Ahmedabad—rather than favouring either side.
- Well-Known Mark Claims Under Section 2(1)(zg): Even high-value suits seeking Rs. 2 crore+ in damages and well-known trademark declarations before a High Court's Commercial Division can be transferred by the Supreme Court for unified trial alongside a competing district commercial suit.
For commercial litigation, trademark protection, and Supreme Court transfer guidance, visit https://sklawhouse.com/posts or contact https://sklawhouse.com/contact-us.
Drafting Effective Section 25 CPC Transfer Petitions in Multi-State IP Battles
When preparing a Transfer Petition (Civil) under Section 25 CPC in cross commercial trademark disputes like M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170), advocates should structure the petition around four concrete pillars: (1) a side-by-side tabular comparison of the reliefs, parties, and impugned trademark in both plaints (demonstrating complete overlap of core issues); (2) certified copies of the plaints, written statements, and pending interim injunction applications in both Indore/trial court and High Court proceedings; (3) demonstration of the severe risk of conflicting interim orders affecting pan-India e-commerce platforms and distribution networks; and (4) an open, constructive stance indicating willingness to have both suits consolidated before a single competent commercial court—including a neutral third forum such as the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad—if the opposing party objects to the petitioner's home forum.
Furthermore, corporate legal departments should note that once the Supreme Court transfers a High Court commercial suit (such as CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025) to a City Civil Court, the transferee court acquires full seisin over all pending prayers, including statutory damages, rendition of accounts, and trademark validity/infringement issues, ensuring a single, unified trial and appealable decree.
Comparative Matrix: Indore Suit vs. Delhi High Court Suit Consolidated at Ahmedabad
To appreciate the symmetry of the Supreme Court's consolidation order in M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170), corporate counsel can compare the two competing actions:
- Indore Suit — CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025: Filed by M/s Supremo India Private Limited before the District Judge (Commercial), Indore, seeking permanent injunction against use of 'SUPREME', asset disclosure/restraint, removal of goods from third-party interactive e-commerce platforms, and Rs. 15,00,000/- damages.
- Delhi Suit — CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025: Filed by M/s The Supreme Industries Limited before the High Court of Delhi, seeking injunctions against registered trademark infringement, passing off, copyright infringement in the 'SUPREME' label/logo, trademark dilution and tarnishment, rendition of accounts, delivery-up and destruction of infringing goods, Rs. 2,00,01,000/- damages, and declaration of 'SUPREME' as a well-known trademark under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
- Supreme Court Resolution: Both Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 3594 of 2025 and Transfer Petition (Civil) No. 175 of 2026 were disposed of by transferring both suits to the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad, with directions for expeditious record transmission and party appearance on 26 November 2026.
Key Litigation Lessons From Supreme Industries v. Supremo India (2026 INSC 1170)
For trademark owners, commercial litigators, and corporate general counsel across India, M/s The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/s Supremo India Private Limited (2026 INSC 1170) underscores three enduring strategic principles:
- Preventing Fragmented IP Adjudication: When two companies sue each other in different States (such as Indore and New Delhi) over the same trademark ('SUPREME'), consolidation before a single commercial forum is essential to avoid conflicting injunctions, inconsistent e-commerce takedowns, and duplicated witness trials.
- Judicial Neutrality in Forum Deadlocks: When both parties insist on transferring the rival suit to their own home court while opposing the other's jurisdiction, the Supreme Court will readily exercise Section 25 CPC discretion to select a neutral third commercial venue—here, the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
- Preservation of Substantive Merits: Transfer orders under Section 25 CPC do not prejudice either party's substantive claims regarding prior user, deceptive similarity, passing off, copyright infringement, damages, or well-known trademark status under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999; all issues are tried afresh on merits by the transferee court.
7. FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)
Why did the Supreme Court transfer both the Delhi High Court and Indore trademark suits to Ahmedabad?
Because both parties agreed that the cross-suits should be tried by a single Court to avoid conflicting decisions, yet each opposed the other's home forum, the Supreme Court selected a neutral forum—the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad—in 2026 INSC 1170.
Did the Supreme Court comment on who owns the 'SUPREME' trademark?
No. Justice S.V.N. Bhatti expressly clarified that the Court expressed no view on the merits of the trademark, copyright, or well-known mark claims, leaving all substantive issues for the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
When were the parties directed to appear before the transferee court?
The Supreme Court directed both parties to appear before the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad on 26 November 2026.
Can a Commercial Suit pending in a High Court be transferred to a City Civil Court in another State?
Yes. Under Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, the Supreme Court has plenary power to transfer a suit from a High Court in one State (here, CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025 before the Delhi High Court) to a competent Civil/Commercial Court in another State (the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad) to be tried alongside a cross-suit.
What reliefs were sought in the two cross-suits in Supreme Industries v. Supremo India?
In Indore (CS (Comm) No. 134/2025), Supremo India sought an injunction against use of 'SUPREME', asset disclosure, e-commerce restraint, and Rs. 15 lakhs damages. In Delhi (CS (Comm) No. 1294/2025), Supreme Industries sought injunctions for trademark infringement, passing off, copyright infringement, dilution, rendition of accounts, delivery-up, Rs. 2,00,01,000/- damages, and a well-known mark declaration under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
How does this judgment help Tamil Nadu businesses facing out-of-state trademark suits?
If a Tamil Nadu business is sued in another State over a mark it is already litigating in Chennai, it can petition the Supreme Court under Section 25 CPC to consolidate both suits before one court, avoiding conflicting injunctions and duplicate trial costs.
Does transferring a suit under Section 25 CPC affect interim injunctions already passed?
All existing orders and pleadings travel with the transferred plaint to the transferee court (here, the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad), which then exercises full jurisdiction to hear pending interim applications and conduct a consolidated trial.
Can a defendant in a trademark suit file a counter-suit in another State to force a settlement?
While parties sometimes file cross-suits in different States, the Supreme Court's ruling in 2026 INSC 1170 shows that cross-suits will be consolidated before a single court—potentially a neutral third forum like Ahmedabad—eliminating tactical forum advantages.
What is the significance of Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 cited in the Delhi suit?
Section 2(1)(zg) defines a 'well-known trade mark'—a mark that has become so widely known to the substantial segment of the public that its use on unrelated goods would indicate a connection with the proprietor, conferring broad cross-class protection.
Which two specific commercial suits were consolidated by the Supreme Court in 2026 INSC 1170?
The Supreme Court consolidated CS (Comm) No. 134 of 2025 pending before the District Judge (Commercial), Indore, Madhya Pradesh, and CS (Comm) No. 1294 of 2025 pending before the High Court of Delhi, transferring both to the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad.
Why did the Supreme Court direct the parties to appear on 26 November 2026?
Fixing a concrete appearance date—26 November 2026—before the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad ensures that neither party delays proceedings after the Indore and Delhi registries transmit the plaints and records.
What damages were claimed in the respective Indore and Delhi trademark suits?
Supremo India claimed Rs. 15,00,000/- in its Indore suit, while Supreme Industries claimed Rs. 2,00,01,000/- jointly and severally in its Delhi High Court suit alongside a well-known mark declaration under Section 2(1)(zg).
Who appeared as Senior Counsel for the parties before the Supreme Court?
Senior Counsel Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul and Senior Counsel Ms. S. Janani appeared for the respective parties before Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria.
